Singapore’s AI Education Policy: A Model for Inclusive Upskilling?

Table of Contents

• Introduction
• Background and Context of Singapore’s AI Education Policy
• Detailed Analysis of Singapore’s Policy
  • An Overview of the SkillsFuture Scheme
• Is Singapore’s Policy Inclusive?
• Areas for Improvement and Recommendations
• Conclusion
• Who Are We?
• References

Introduction

Under Budget 2024, Singapore has launched initiatives to upskill its workforce, particularly citizens aged 40 and above. With a $4,000 SkillsFuture credit top-up and subsidies for educational programs, the aim is to enhance mid-career workers’ capabilities in AI and related fields in Singapore’s AI education policy, ensuring competitiveness in the evolving job market.

As Singapore harnesses its sophisticated education system, it must address the ethical and social challenges, including data privacy, algorithmic bias, and job security posed by AI integration. This is crucial for the 40 and over demographic, who may be more vulnerable to automation disruptions.

Inclusivity in AI education is key to preventing skill gaps and making programs accessible and beneficial. Singapore’s focus on developing policies and practices around Singapore’s AI education policy reflects a commitment to preparing individuals for future job markets while addressing ethical concerns.

Background and Context of Singapore’s AI Education Policy

Globally, countries recognize the importance of AI upskilling as crucial in maintaining competitiveness in a tech-driven economy. For instance, in April 2021, the EU proposed the world’s first regulatory framework for AI to ensure safe and trustworthy AI systems, emphasizing mandatory transparency and accountability requirements.

Likewise, Canada’s Pan-Canadian Artificial Intelligence Strategy focuses on research, talent development, and industry collaboration to support the AI industry’s growth, with world-leading AI research hubs established in key cities like Toronto–Waterloo, Montréal, Edmonton, and Vancouver. Both initiatives reflect a global recognition of the importance of digital and Singapore’s AI education policy skills in developing economic growth and competitiveness.

Singapore, a forerunner in technological adoption, has fitted well with this trend by introducing the AI upskilling initiative. While Singapore’s AI education policy aligns with global best practices, the targeted demographics make this move a contrasting one. While the other policies focus more on preparing the younger generations for the AI revolution, Singapore has strayed a bit by targeting mid-career workers, who often find it tough to bounce back from unemployment and unexpected layoffs.

This move is also politically skillful. According to the Labour Force in Singapore 2022, Singapore’s resident population has continued to age, with the median age reaching 42.1 years as of June 2022 and the proportion of residents aged 65 years and over increasing to 16.6%. 

Detailed Analysis of Singapore’s Policy

An Overview of the SkillsFuture Scheme

• Eligibility Criteria: The SkillsFuture Credit (SFC) scheme is open to all Singaporeans aged 25 and above, with specific enhancements for citizens aged 40 and above. These enhancements include a substantial SGD 4,000 Skills Future credit top-up to encourage mid-career workers to engage in AI and related fields.
• Funding Structures: The government allocates credits that can be used for a wide range of approved courses. The funding structure includes significant subsidies for those aged 40 and above to offset upskilling and reskilling costs. This funding is offered under the SkillsFuture Level-Up program (SFLP), which is jointly sponsored by the Ministry of Education and SkillsFuture Singapore.
• Types of Courses Offered: The SFC scheme encompasses a diverse array of courses, including Data Analytics, Digital Media, Cybersecurity, and other AI-related subjects. Major universities, polytechnics, and private providers offer these courses, ensuring a wide selection for learners.

The policy targets mid-career workers aged 40 and above, providing additional credits to this demographic. This focus acknowledges the need to keep older workers competitive in an evolving job market, addressing their challenges in keeping up with technological advancements. Singapore’s SkillsFuture initiative represents a proactive and inclusive approach to upskilling the nation’s workforce in the age of artificial intelligence (AI).

Recognizing the profound impact of AI on the labor market, the Singaporean government has taken decisive steps to equip its citizens with the necessary skills to thrive in an AI-driven economy. By leveraging the SkillsFuture Credit (SFC) scheme and Singapore’s AI education policy targeted enhancements, Singapore aims to address the diverse needs of its workforce, including those traditionally disadvantaged in digital adoption.

This inclusive approach is evident in its broad eligibility criteria, which welcomes all Singaporeans aged 25 and above, irrespective of their prior qualifications or occupations. The openness offered by this scheme acknowledges the heterogeneity of the workforce and the varying skill levels and backgrounds that individuals bring to the table.

Furthermore, the scheme’s specific enhancements for citizens aged 40 and above demonstrate a commitment to addressing the unique challenges mid-career professionals face in adapting to the rapidly evolving technological landscape.

The substantial SGD 4,000 SkillsFuture credit top-up for this demographic is a significant incentive, encouraging individuals to invest in upskilling and reskilling themselves in Singapore’s AI education policy and related fields.

However, all these criteria must also be evaluated from a sociopolitical angle. Singapore’s ecosystem of accelerators, incubators, and the presence of around 3,600 tech-driven companies make it one of the most well-developed startup environments globally. Foreign investors increasingly support Singapore’s AI startups, signaling strong confidence in its Singapore’s AI education policy technology sector.

For instance, WIZ.AI, a conversational AI startup, secured $30 million in Series A funding from Chinese equity firms in June 2022. Another notable example is Bolttech, an AI firm specializing in mobile device diagnostics, which garnered $180 million from U.S. investors, followed by an additional $30 million from Spanish and Singaporean backers, including EDBI.

These investments of Singapore’s AI education policy demonstrate the global investment community’s acknowledgment of the opportunities available in Singapore. Therefore, the Singaporean government’s interest in strengthening the mid-career workforce is hardly surprising. 

It is precisely for this purpose the SkillsFuture Level-Up program (SFLP) was designed. The SFLP—by providing targeted funding and resources—acknowledges the unique challenges faced by this demographic and aims to facilitate their successful transition into the AI-driven workforce.

Therefore, it offers a wide range of subjects, spanning data analytics, digital media, cybersecurity, and other AI-related subjects. These courses are developed by major universities, polytechnics, and private providers, preparing 40+ aged Singaporeans to adapt and thrive in an ever-changing job market.

Is Singapore’s Policy Inclusive?

While the SkillsFuture initiative is well-rounded, thoughtful, and insightful, there are also certain pitfalls from an inclusive angle. Undoubtedly, the SkillsFuture initiative represents a commendable effort towards inclusive upskilling, but there is also a significant limitation – the exclusion of migrant workers from these programs. In 2019, out of Singapore’s 1.4 million foreign workers, approximately 999,000 were employed under low-wage work permits.

Drawn by the promise of higher wages, these workers, primarily from South and Southeast Asia, occupy essential roles in sectors such as construction, manufacturing, and domestic services—positions often overlooked by local citizens. Many migrant workers in Singapore already face substantial financial burdens, including accruing debt from basic training and certification fees required to work there. Excluding them from the SkillsFuture initiative’s upskilling opportunities further compounds their vulnerabilities in the face of AI-driven job displacement.

The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the vulnerabilities in Singapore, particularly during times of crisis. Economic instability, combined with border closures and increased xenophobia, disproportionately affected foreign workers. At one point, 88% of the COVID-19 cases were in migrant worker housing areas, calling attention to the inequality in Singaporean society. The pandemic-induced restrictions forced many workers to leave Singapore abruptly and have struggled to return.

The rapid digitalization response to COVID-19 has also spurred a surge in AI and robotic deployments, especially in sectors that predominantly employ migrant workers. This shift will require an additional 1.2 million digitally skilled workers by 2025. Consequently, many migrant workers might be unable to meet the new demands and forced out of the workforce. 

AI’s role in potentially devaluing the contributions of migrant workers could lead to even lower wages and poorer living and working conditions. Migrant workers from India and Bangladesh, for example, earn just a fraction of the average Singaporean salary, and their living conditions during the pandemic were widely criticized internationally.

These factors underscore the urgent need for Singapore to reevaluate its approach to foreign labor and AI, ensuring it leads with ethical practices that respect and protect all workers.

Areas for Improvement and Recommendations

To address the limitations of the SkillsFuture initiative and ensure a truly inclusive approach to AI upskilling, The Inclusive AI suggests the following recommendations:

• Extend SkillsFuture benefits to migrant workers. By granting migrant workers access to the SkillsFuture Credit scheme and its associated subsidies, Singapore can empower this vulnerable segment of the workforce to acquire the necessary AI-related skills, reducing their risk of job displacement.
• Collaborate with regional partners. Singapore can leverage its leadership position in AI adoption to collaborate with neighboring countries and establish region-wide standards for worker rights and skill development. Regular reports on AI-driven job displacement trends and skill demands within the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) can help policymakers and individuals mitigate potential labor supply shocks.
• Reframe perceptions of “skill” and “value”. Singapore must reevaluate its conceptions of value and expertise, moving beyond narrow definitions that devalue the contributions of specific workforce segments. By developing a more inclusive and nuanced understanding of what it means to be “skilled” or “unskilled,” Singapore can pave the way for a more constructive societal relationship with AI and promote greater appreciation for all forms of labor.
• Safeguard rights for AI-affected workers. Establishing buffer periods for displaced workers to find new employment before facing deportation, as suggested by worker rights organizations, can serve as a stopgap measure to protect the livelihoods of migrant workers impacted by AI automation.

By embracing these recommendations and adopting a more inclusive approach to AI upskilling, Singapore can be a true leader in AI adoption and ethical labor practices.

Conclusion

Singapore’s AI education policy represents a significant stride towards fostering a resilient, adaptable workforce ready to thrive in an AI-driven future. By focusing on mid-career professionals aged 40 and above, the policy addresses a crucial demographic often overlooked in technology upskilling initiatives.

The $4,000 SkillsFuture credit top-up and extensive subsidies illustrate a strong governmental commitment to workforce development in crucial AI and tech-related fields.

While the policy’s broad eligibility criteria and substantial financial incentives reflect a robust framework, there are limitations to its reach. Notably, the exclusion of migrant workers and potential barriers such as financial constraints and system complexity highlight areas where the policy could truly embody inclusivity. 

To enhance the effectiveness and inclusivity of Singapore’s AI education initiatives, stakeholders should amend the policy to include migrant workers and other marginalized groups, ensuring that all population sectors can benefit from AI upskilling opportunities.

Additionally, reducing the program’s complexity and adjusting funding structures to cover more costs associated with high-quality AI training courses would further strengthen the policy’s impact and promote a genuinely inclusive approach to AI education in Singapore.

Who Are We?

As a pioneer in AI inclusivity, The Inclusive AI (TIA) is dedicated to championing diversity and inclusion in AI. Our mission aligns closely with the need for ethical AI practices prioritizing inclusivity and accessibility, ensuring that AI developments benefit everyone equally.

By advocating for policies that enhance AI literacy and reviewing applications for bias, TIA strives to ensure that AI technologies are a force for good, bridging gaps rather than widening them. Organizations looking to align with these ideals can leverage TIA’s expertise to ensure their AI implementations are free from bias and contribute positively to creating an inclusive society. 

Together, let us work towards a future where AI transforms economies and develops an inclusive society that values every individual’s contribution.

References

Boonpratakvej, N. (2021, November 29). Will Singapore forget its low-paid migrant workers again? New Mandala. https://www.newmandala.org/will-singapore-forget-its-low-paid-migrant-workers-again/

Department of Statistics Singapore. (n.d.). Population Trends 2022. In singstat.gov.sg. Retrieved May 14, 2024, from https://www.singstat.gov.sg/-/media/files/publications/population/population2022.ashx

Goode, K., Kim, H. M., & Deng, M. (2023). Examining Singapore’s AI progress. https://doi.org/10.51593/2021ca014

Guang-Xi, J. O. (2022, July 29). The Big Read: The COVID-19-induced foreigners’ exodus — will they return to Singapore and what if they don’t? CNA. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/covid-19-foreigners-exodus-what-will-happen-2468096

Hennebry, J., & H, KC. (2020). Quarantined! Xenophobia and migrant workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. In iom.int. International Organization for Migration. Retrieved May 14, 2024, from https://publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/quarantined.pdf

Ho, T. (2024, January 18). Commentary: What AI’s rise means for the “who, why, what and how of reskilling” in Singapore. TODAY. https://www.todayonline.com/commentary/commentary-what-ais-rise-means-who-why-what-and-how-reskilling-singapore-2217431

Kim, S., Chen, Z. W., Tan, J. Q., & Mussagulova, A. (2021). A case study of the Singapore SkillsFuture Credit scheme: preliminary insights for making lifelong learning policy more effective. Asian Journal of Political Science, 29(2), 192–214. https://doi.org/10.1080/02185377.2021.1917431

LABOUR FORCE IN SINGAPORE 2022. (n.d.). In mom.gov.sg. Retrieved May 14, 2024, from https://stats.mom.gov.sg/iMAS_PdfLibrary/mrsd_2022LabourForce_survey_findings.pdf

Lee, A. V. Y., Koh, E., & Looi, C. (2023). AI in Education and Learning Analytics in Singapore: An Overview of Key Projects and Initiatives. Information and Technology in Education and Learning, 3(1), Inv-p001. https://doi.org/10.12937/itel.3.1.inv.p001

Securing Canada’s AI advantage. (2024, April 7). Prime Minister of Canada. https://www.pm.gc.ca/en/news/news-releases/2024/04/07/securing-canadas-ai

SkillsFuture Series. (n.d.). SkillsFuture SG. https://www.skillsfuture.gov.sg/initiatives/mid-career/series

Tilo, D. (2024, February 16). Singapore unveils $4,000 SkillsFuture Credit top-up to help mid-career workers. HRD Asia. https://www.hcamag.com/asia/specialisation/learning-development/singapore-unveils-4000-skillsfuture-credit-top-up-to-help-mid-career-workers/477578

Unnikrishna. (2024, March 4). Singapore’s Bold AI Policy: Offers Subsidized Education for Adults 40+ to Keep Pace with Rapidly Changing World. Medium. https://unnikrishna.medium.com/singapores-bold-ai-policy-offers-subsidized-education-for-adults-40-to-keep-pace-with-rapidly-d3dbeabf4efb